Comments on: Choosen Teams http://www.boontan.net/2009/02/02/choosen-teams/ Wed, 01 Feb 2012 00:49:58 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3 By: Riogi http://www.boontan.net/2009/02/02/choosen-teams/comment-page-1/#comment-849 Riogi Tue, 03 Feb 2009 15:53:19 +0000 http://www.boontan.net/?p=1147#comment-849 In the previous news... They're not that hard to find, aren't they? Sample: "seriously, I’d leave out chihiro if there are other better groups. Maria+Holic is gg, definitely. Coalguys for Asu is quite reasonable. Take Bandaiatv for Kurokami, its in HD. As for Zoku, all of them seems decent." Now: 1-that comment; 2-my own experience; 3-the fact that when you add all the total votes (I admit the quoted comment is the biggest one against the Chihiro releases, but I've taken every comment in consideration for the results, including the positive ones) of the members about each series, Chihiro is still left behind on every single show; 4-the average rating on AniDB is far greater for CG (while the number of the votes is the same). Those are the reasons why we won't stick with Chihiro releases. And what comment did you speak about? The only serious comment I've read on AniDB is a comment where the guy says in conclusion that he'll take another team firstly (the one with translation comparisons)... In the previous news… They’re not that hard to find, aren’t they? Sample: “seriously, I’d leave out chihiro if there are other better groups. Maria+Holic is gg, definitely. Coalguys for Asu is quite reasonable. Take Bandaiatv for Kurokami, its in HD. As for Zoku, all of them seems decent.”

Now:
1-that comment;
2-my own experience;
3-the fact that when you add all the total votes (I admit the quoted comment is the biggest one against the Chihiro releases, but I’ve taken every comment in consideration for the results, including the positive ones) of the members about each series, Chihiro is still left behind on every single show;
4-the average rating on AniDB is far greater for CG (while the number of the votes is the same).
Those are the reasons why we won’t stick with Chihiro releases.

And what comment did you speak about? The only serious comment I’ve read on AniDB is a comment where the guy says in conclusion that he’ll take another team firstly (the one with translation comparisons)…

]]> By: Sandy Wichs Boy http://www.boontan.net/2009/02/02/choosen-teams/comment-page-1/#comment-848 Sandy Wichs Boy Tue, 03 Feb 2009 12:25:44 +0000 http://www.boontan.net/?p=1147#comment-848 Where are these comments saying CG is better than Chihiro? I actually decided to go with Chihiro's release based on the comments I read on AniDB. I've never been to Chihiro's chan either. Where are these comments saying CG is better than Chihiro?
I actually decided to go with Chihiro’s release based on the comments I read on AniDB. I’ve never been to Chihiro’s chan either.

]]> By: Riogi http://www.boontan.net/2009/02/02/choosen-teams/comment-page-1/#comment-847 Riogi Tue, 03 Feb 2009 09:04:15 +0000 http://www.boontan.net/?p=1147#comment-847 Bet you heard that on Chihiro's chan? :p No offense, I like their work too, but it seems that the coalguys' one is better. Either on AniDB.net or here coal is winning in terms of positive feedback. Oh, and I'll delete your first post. Bet you heard that on Chihiro’s chan? :p

No offense, I like their work too, but it seems that the coalguys’ one is better. Either on AniDB.net or here coal is winning in terms of positive feedback.

Oh, and I’ll delete your first post.

]]> By: Sandy Wichs Boy http://www.boontan.net/2009/02/02/choosen-teams/comment-page-1/#comment-846 Sandy Wichs Boy Tue, 03 Feb 2009 05:47:09 +0000 http://www.boontan.net/?p=1147#comment-846 Why are you going with the Coalguys release of Akikan? I’ve reead that Chihiro’s releases are far closer to the original in terms of translation. EDIT: Chihiro's release is higher resolution too. I thought you guys were all about HD over SD? (sorry for the double post, my browser was playing up and now I can't find a way to edit the previous post) Why are you going with the Coalguys release of Akikan? I’ve reead that Chihiro’s releases are far closer to the original in terms of translation.

EDIT: Chihiro’s release is higher resolution too. I thought you guys were all about HD over SD?

(sorry for the double post, my browser was playing up and now I can’t find a way to edit the previous post)

]]> By: Nunuhaza http://www.boontan.net/2009/02/02/choosen-teams/comment-page-1/#comment-842 Nunuhaza Mon, 02 Feb 2009 09:30:25 +0000 http://www.boontan.net/?p=1147#comment-842 could someone tell me who has been putting up updates on the wrong date? because from time to time i see things like the 28th, updates added when its the 31st. could someone tell me who has been putting up updates on the wrong date? because from time to time i see things like the 28th, updates added when its the 31st.

]]>